BRIGHTON (AP) — A judge facing criminal charges and ethics violations was removed from office last Friday by the Michigan Supreme Court.
The court’s decision against Livingston County Judge Theresa Brennan was unanimous and came just nine days after justices heard arguments. The Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission had recommended her removal.
Brennan was accused of many ethics violations in how she ran her office as well as for a relationship with a state police detective during a murder trial. Separately, she was ordered to trial last week on charges of perjury and destroying evidence in her divorce case.
“We adopt the commission’s findings of fact because our review of the record reveals that they are amply supported,” the Supreme Court said.
In a footnote, the court added: “We are not often confronted with the multifarious acts of misconduct that are present in this case.”
Brennan’s attorney, Dennis Kolenda, told the court that phone calls and text messages between her and a state police detective weren’t proof of an improper relationship with a key investigator during a murder trial.
“Maybe there was a little, a little — I don’t think there was — a little misconduct that ought to be dealt with less than a hanging,” Kolenda said, adding that removing Brennan from the bench was “way out of proportion.”
Brennan had been a judge since 2005. Her term would have ended at the end of 2020.
- Posted July 02, 2019
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Michigan Supreme Court removes judge from office

headlines Oakland County
- Whitmer signs gun violence prevention legislation
- Department of Attorney General conducts statewide warrant sweep, arrests 9
- Adoptive families across Michigan recognized during Adoption Day and Month
- Reproductive Health Act signed into law
- Case study: Documentary highlights history of courts in the Eastern District
headlines National
- Oscar vs. Jeff: Trial lawyers and appellate counsel do different jobs, and it may show in their writing
- ‘Can a killer look like a granny?’ Prosecutor poses questions as mother-in-law of slain law prof goes on trial
- ILTACON 2025: The Wild, Wild West of legal tech
- After striking deal with Trump, this BigLaw firm worked with liberal groups to secure pro bono wins in 2 cases
- ‘Early decision conspiracy’ among top colleges is an antitrust violation, suit alleges
- Striking the Balance: How to make alternative fee arrangements work for everyone