WMU-Cooley Innocence Project paves the way for man's release after 32 years

Gilbert Poole walks out of prison in Jackson, with Cooley Law School Innocence Project Attorneys Marla Mitchell-Cichon and David Williams.

Photo courtesy of WMU-Cooley Law School

On May 26, Oakland County Circuit Judge Rae Lee Chabot set aside the conviction of Gilbert Lee Poole, Jr. wrongfully convicted of murder in 1989.

“I have to say that I didn’t understand what was happening back in 1988 when I came to court to be tried for a murder I didn’t commit. At 22 years old, and a thousand miles away from anyone I knew, I kicked and screamed and stomped my feet and said this is not right,” Poole said during the hearing.

Assistant Attorney General Robyn Frankel, director of the Michigan Attorney General’s Conviction Integrity Unit, moved to have Poole’s conviction vacated and requested dismissal of all charges. Poole is represented by Marla Mitchell-Cichon of the Western Michigan University Cooley Law School Innocence Project (WMU-Cooley Innocence Project).

“Mr. Poole’s conviction was based on unreliable evidence, including a bite mark comparison, which is not based on science,” said Mitchell-Cichon.

DNA testing excluded Poole from the crime scene and implicated an unknown individual. “I commend the Michigan Attorney General and her establishment of a conviction integrity unit that will investigate claims of innocence and uncover the truth,” said Mitchell-Cichon.

“I spent decades learning, reading, studying law, but none of that was working for me,” Poole said. “It wasn’t until I surrendered to a higher power and God stepped in and sent me a band of angels to look past the rules and regulations and looked to see who was standing in the furnace. I was standing in the furnace. I didn’t belong here. I have to thank each and every one of you, without you this wasn’t possible.”

The statewide conviction integrity unit reviews claims of innocence in all counties, except Wayne , which has its own unit.

On June 7, 1988, the body of Robert Mejia was found near a running path in Pontiac. Mejia had been stabbed to death. He was last seen alive at a Pontiac bar and several bar patrons provided a description of a man who was with Mejia when he left the bar. Based on those descriptions, composite drawings were posted in the Oakland Press, but no leads developed and the case went cold.
In November 1988, Poole’s then girlfriend implicated Poole in the murder. Despite her inability to provide accurate details about when the crime occurred, she became the state’s key witness.

Dr. Allan Warnick, DDS, who has been associated with other wrongful convictions, was the only witness to tie Poole to the crime scene through his comparison of Poole’s teeth to a presumed bite mark on the victim’s arm. Bite mark comparisons have since been debunked by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) and the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST). Even the American Society of Odontology no longer stands by the practices used in Poole’s case. 

Several blood stains were collected from the crime scene, and blood on a stone found embedded in the victim’s body did not match the victim nor Poole. That evidence was never presented at trial due to the failures of Poole’s trial counsel. In 2016, DNA testing of that same sample and other blood samples confirmed that an individual other than the victim and Poole left their blood behind. Dr. Karl Reich of Independent Forensics conducted a thorough review of the testing results and concluded “the defendant is excluded as a contributor to all tested samples and there is evidence of an unknown contributor who is not the defendant or the victim.”

The WMU-Cooley Innocence Project filed an application with the Michigan Attorney General’s Conviction Integrity Unit and the unit reinvestigated the case. Based on their investigation, Frankel moved to set aside Poole’s conviction.

“This case serves as an example of the important work being done by our Conviction Integrity Unit,” said Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel. “When we established this team in 2019, we made a commitment to ensuring those convicted of state crimes are, in fact, guilty while also providing justice to those wrongfully imprisoned. I appreciate the tireless work the unit put in alongside the WMU-Cooley Innocence Project to reach this outcome for Mr. Poole.”

In 2018, the Department of the Michigan Attorney General received a Post-Conviction DNA Testing of Evidence grant from the Department of Justice to screen claims of innocence and conduct DNA testing in appropriate cases. In 2019, the Cooley Innocence Project received an Upholding the Rule of Law grant from the DOJ to review cases in which unreliable forensics played a role in the conviction. Since 2018, the two offices have been partnering on DNA and other forensic casework. This partnership led to Gilbert Poole’s release after 32 long years.