––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://test.legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available
- Posted December 29, 2010
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Supreme Court urged by ABA to consider age in determining Miranda custody, questioning
The American Bar Association last week urged the Supreme Court of the United States to reverse a decision of the Supreme Court of North Carolina that held that age could not be considered in making a Miranda custody determination in a case involving a 13-year old who was questioned by a police officer in a school conference room, in the presence of another police officer and the school's vice principal. In its amicus filing in J.D.B. v. State of North Carolina, the ABA requests the high court reverse the decision, and hold that a Miranda custody determination for persons under the age of 18 must include a determination of whether a reasonable person of that age would have felt free to terminate police questioning and leave.
The question of whether age may be considered in a Miranda custody determination was left open by the U.S. Supreme Court in prior case law. The ABA's amicus brief cites work done by the ABA and research studies that show that juveniles differ from adults developmentally, in ways that make them "more susceptible to influence and intimidation, and more likely to falsely confess to an offense they did not commit." The factors discussed include diminished maturity, self-restraint, experience, judgment and decision-making capability, reduced capacity to assist in their own defense, and less appreciation of the long-term consequences of their actions. The filed amicus brief will be available here.
The ABA has adopted a number of policies relating to improvement of the juvenile justice system, and the brief cites the association's Juvenile Justice Standards as well as a report by the ABA Task Force on Youth in the Criminal Justice System: Guidelines for Policymakers and Practitioners, adopted by the association's policymaking House of Delegates in 2002.
Published: Wed, Dec 29, 2010
headlines Oakland County
- Whitmer signs gun violence prevention legislation
- Department of Attorney General conducts statewide warrant sweep, arrests 9
- Adoptive families across Michigan recognized during Adoption Day and Month
- Reproductive Health Act signed into law
- Case study: Documentary highlights history of courts in the Eastern District
headlines National
- Judge is accused of using racial slur, vulgar terms and ‘libtard’ label for employee offended by his comments
- ACLU and BigLaw firm use ‘Orange is the New Black’ in hashtag effort to promote NY jail reform
- Colorado Supreme Court considers whether habeas petition can free zoo elephants
- 4th Circuit upholds $1M sanction for law firm that tried to ‘sabotage’ federal court’s authority
- Don’t give money to law schools unless they teach originalism, conservative federal appeals judge says
- Average BigLaw partner compensation increased 26% in 2 years, reaching this high-water mark