Alyssa Evans, Wealth of Geeks
Real Estate Witch asked 1,000 millennials about their finances, their debts, and how they feel about their financial prospects. What they discovered was that America’s poorest generation may be even worse off than previously thought.
Millennials came of age in a struggling economy. Now the debts they’ve taken on, in many cases, just to afford necessities, are having serious, far-ranging effects on their financial health.
Many have given up on ever owning a home or having kids, according to the Real Estate Witch study.
Just how much debt do millennials have? The survey found that almost three-quarters of millennials (72%) carry non-mortgage debt and that the average millennial owes $117,000. Only 10% of millennials have never had any debt, and only 28% are presently debt-free.
So how has that affected their lifestyles?
—————
Off to a rough start
The oldest millennials reached adulthood around the 2008 financial crash. They entered a job market offering reduced salaries and shaky job security. Beginning their careers in an era when housing, education, and general living costs have far outpaced wage growth has caused many to delay or forego the buying and selling of their first home, and many have postponed starting a family.
On top of that, they have also taken on previously unheard-of levels of college debt, as the cost of tuition skyrocketed post-2000. Some analysts call millennials the poorest generation because they’ve amassed wealth at a much slower pace than previous generations while also being squeezed by increasing costs.
Their slow start left them uniquely unprepared for the economic disruptions of the pandemic, which hit many millennials just as they were entering their prime earning years. As a result, many millennials have embraced a frugal lifestyle out of necessity.
To cut costs, over half of millennials (54%) regularly cook instead of eating out, and nearly half (45%) buy generic goods instead of name-brand. Other common ways that millennials save money include limiting or canceling subscription services (39%), buying used goods (35%), avoiding driving (25%), and renting instead of buying a home (24%).
On top of that, just over a quarter of millennials (26%) work multiple jobs to make ends meet. The millennial necessity to save money has had wide-ranging effects on our economy, spawning everything from cord-cutting to flat fee real estate brokers.
—————
A lot of millennials have saved money — but many haven’t
The average millennial has saved $49,463, which is more or less in line with expert recommendations that one should save 1X their annual income by age 30. (U.S. workers earn a median salary of $54,000.)
But many millennials have saved far less than that. The study found that 1 in 7 millennials reported having no money saved at all, and one-fourth of millennials (25%) aren’t confident they could cover a $500 emergency expense. A third (33%) doubt they could afford a $1,000 emergency expense, and nearly half (48%) doubt they could cover a $5,000 emergency expense - suggesting the average amount of millennial savings is skewed upwards by a relatively small percentage of high-savings individuals.
Because most millennials don’t have a lot of cash on hand, many turn to high-interest loans or credit cards to cover unexpected expenses; a major factor in the high levels of debt carried by this generation.
—————
Millennials are carrying unprecedented amounts of debt
While millennials have a lot of student debt, this generation’s leading type of non-mortgage debt is credit card debt.
Just over two-thirds of millennials (67%) have credit card debt, and the study found the average balance was $5,349, slightly less than the average balance among all Americans. A large part of that is due to the simple fact that many millennials are relatively young; average balances were about 20% higher among older millennials, who’ve had a few more years to accumulate debt.
The study found that 29% of millennials don’t pay their credit card bill in full every month and that nearly a quarter of these respondents owe $10,000 or more. Although carrying a large amount of high-interest debt, like credit card debt, is viewed by many experts as financially irresponsible, only one-fifth of respondents (20%) said they regretted not paying off their credit card debt. This suggests many millennials don’t object to paying fees or surcharges like credit card interest or real estate commission, viewing them as simple transaction costs.
One interesting related finding: around 16% of millennials refused to get a credit card at all. The top reason cited for not having one? Fear of going into credit card debt.
—————
Millennials have a ton of student debt
Some millennials’ wariness around credit cards may be due to their experiences with student debt. Almost 15 million have student debt, more than any other generation. How ubiquitous are student loans among this generation? Only 8% of respondents said they’d never taken out any student loans.
Overall, 48% of millennials carry student debt, with an average balance of $126,993.
The sheer pace of skyrocketing tuition costs is reflected in the student debt levels of older millennials vs. younger millennials. The older millennials averaged around $111,000 in student loans, while their younger counterparts averaged $135,000 - a huge disparity, considering they attended college barely a decade apart.
Student debt is an investment not only in education but in a student’s future — specifically, their future earnings. However, for millennials, education hasn’t been the wisest investment.
The average U.S. full-time worker makes around $54,000 a year as of 2022, but millennials fall slightly below that level; 40% of millennials make less than $50,000 a year, and almost one in five millennials (19%) make less than $25,000 a year.
In light of those numbers, it’s no surprise that millennials have serious regrets. Almost a quarter (24%) regret not choosing a career with more earning potential, and 22% regret taking out student loans in the first place.
—————
Housing eats up a lot of millennial budgets
As home values and rents have vastly outpaced income gains, millennials have been forced to put more and more of their income towards housing.
The average millennial spends 47% of their gross monthly income on housing, which is around 1.5x more than the 30% that financial experts suggest allocating towards housing. Half of all millennials spend 50% or more of their income on housing, with two-thirds spending more than the recommended proportion of 30%. By the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development standards, these millennial households are “severely cost-burdened” or “cost-burdened.”
For comparison, only 22% and 28% of households, respectively, were cost-burdened or severely cost-burdened in 2011.
—————
Many millennials have given up on homeownership and starting a family
Given their financial struggles, it’s no surprise that many have simply given up on pricey milestones like buying a home or having kids.
Nearly a third of millennials (30%) who don’t already own a home aren’t looking for a home or a real estate agent; in fact, they don’t think they’ll ever be able to afford one. That number is just slightly higher than the quarter (25%) who say they want children but can’t afford them.
Even so, they may not be missing out on anything. A striking 11% of millennials, or more than one in ten, regret having children. Those numbers escalate for younger millennials, with 37% more likely to regret having kids than their older counterparts.
